Part of the Embarrass River, which would be overwhelmed with toxic sulfide mine tailings by a holding pond failure in this area (threatenedwaters.com).
by Dan Burns
Nov 16, 2026, 6:00 AM

NewRange’s new plan is the worst yet

PolyMet morphed into NewRange some time ago. They’re still bound and determined to undertake sulfide mining for copper and nickel in northern Minnesota. This is from the beginning of a comprehensive and entirely accurate essay about it all.

The northeastern Minnesota project, called NorthMet and owned jointly by Swiss and Canadian companies, would be the first so-called sulfide mine in the state. Sulfide mining is more complicated and produces more toxic waste than Minnesota’s traditional iron mining. Where iron mining waste is stored in tailings basins actually meant to leak a bit, sulfide mining waste storage should be water tight, because the tailings are so toxic.

The stakes could hardly be higher. A catastrophic tailings dam failure could inundate the environmentally sensitive area between Hoyt Lakes and Babbitt with two billion gallons of sulfuric mine waste which would inevitably infiltrate NorthMet on the map of Minnesota into thousands of square miles of the St. Louis River watershed, spreading like blood through capillaries. It has happened in other places like Mount Polley, Canada (2014), Mariana, Brazil (2015), and Brumadinho, Brazil (2019), surprising engineers and geologists.
(Threatened Waters)

This is from an email I got from WaterLegacy:

The NewRange mine would harm more than 1,100 acres of wetlands and construct three new tailings disposal facilities impacting Wyman Creek–a trout stream–and Colby Lake, the drinking water source for the city of Hoyt Lakes. As compared with the PolyMet plan, NewRange would dig deeper mine pits, stockpile more waste rock in taller piles, and provide less wastewater treatment.

Ditto, from Friends of the Boundary Waters:

NewRange redesigned its mine, then asked the state to do a more limited environmental review. They’re trying to set the terms. They want to cut corners.

So (on Nov. 9), with the Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy, we filed a lawsuit, asking the court to reverse the DNR’s decision and require a full, independent environmental review.

This is our moment to make the DNR do its job.

This isn’t just about one mine. If NewRange can cut corners, every mining company eyeing northeastern Minnesota — including Twin Metals at the edge of the Boundary Waters — will take note.

Given the strong record of success in the courts by these exceedingly righteous organizations, along with Indian tribes, I’m fairly confident the DNR will be required to do a full review. But it will take a while, and who knows what NewRange and its ilk will try in the meantime.

To be clear, this is all a separate deal from the Twin Metals proposal, where the US Senate overturned a federal ban last year. The battle over that is ongoing.

Thanks for your feedback. If we like what you have to say, it may appear in a future post of reader reactions.